Song Mode - Sections Palette to draw on the grid

29
rpc9943rpc9943 New York usaPosts: 136

Here's my idea. So we could still have track and song view but if we press shift + song view, it would open up to showing all of the available song section colors on the right hand side as a palette. When we highlight the palette it could then be drawn in to the grid. The idea, is when we press play, it starts on the upper left hand grid pad, and as the song progresses, it will play the next pad to the right. This can repeat across the row until it ends and then continues on the next row down. So more or less we could draw in a blue intro section for pad 1, then hold it down on the grid and set the knob to repeat whatever we want. Then we choose the pink section for example a verse, and draw that in next. This way, we can rapidly arrange and orchestrate everything in a linear fashion and in turn we could easily reuse song sections.

Comments

  • 1
    FASTFAST CaliforniaPosts: 24

    That is exactly how I had 'imagined' that the deluge's song mode would function. However I figured that the deluge could automatically populate the audition pads with the song section colors so that the song could be keyed in very quickly with a self-advancing cursor.

  • 0
    MatthewGeorgeMatthewGeorge Cologne, GermanyPosts: 111
    +1
  • 1
    workergrayworkergray Posts: 113

    the addition of "command" parts like fades, midi program changes, and the ability to input track mutes/unmutes would help too.

  • 0
    neilbaldwinneilbaldwin UKPosts: 21

    This would be a massive workflow boost - great idea Ron!

  • 2
    neilbaldwinneilbaldwin UKPosts: 21

    Had another idea for this:

    By default, the Song should play until there are no more Sections defined.

    To make the Song loop, hold the pad where you want the loop to start and then while holding it tap the pad where the loop should end.

  • 0
    MyrkMyrk Taunton, UKPosts: 70

    So really what you are saying is zooming out another level from Song mode. So track mode, Song Mode, then Song arranger mode, utilizing the same sequence drawing as in track mode to sequence riffs in a song, and using the audition area as an indicator of which track you want to trigger. In essence you are treating the whole song as a drum kit almost. Ingenious! +1

  • 0
    rpc9943rpc9943 New York usaPosts: 136
    Addendum: in this view if we switch to piano view button we could have a playable mode where we trigger the next section so we could have the sections on the grid and trigger them as you would in session mode on novation circuit for example
  • 1
    Lucky_LuxLucky_Lux PolandPosts: 14

    Overall Idea.
    "I'm rather thinking about a "top level" accesed as Ron described "shift + song view" or so. The color coding will be keept. The whole tracks will be displayed as a single grid pad. Sellecting new pad (in the color line) will add new track to the sequance."

    For a better understanding.
    I read your request Ron and, if I understand it right, it can be still problematic. I understand the "section" as a one, or more tracks grouped under the same colour in the song view. If yes, then in your idea, you still need to copy the tracks for a different sections - which causes a current mess with a lot of tracks. After creating sections you propose to places them one another in linear attitude in song mode. Right?

    I think my idea is simplier. In the current song view, you will preapare only tracks and in the song mode the sections. The example from my graphic. Tracks pink and blue will be played "linear" till track blue and green will be played together (and we can call it section - of blue and green).

    Please upvote or... Thank you!

  • 0
    alien_brainalien_brain DetroitPosts: 99

    +1

  • 0
    rpc9943rpc9943 New York usaPosts: 136
    edited October 2017
    Lucky lux I see what you mean but that is very problematic potentially. What I mean is that it would be like drawing the colors in by rows like a section color as a pad that would count up and you can draw in the past color where ever you wanted. No problems there. Blue (4x) red (2x) blue (4x) red (2x) yellow etc. Literally like drawing pixels onto the grid, just a simple playlist for complete songs.
    Post edited by rpc9943 on
  • 0

    for mine, it is not essential to allow two song sections to overlap for the 'song arrangement' mode to be a huge workflow boost - if allowing such overlap (and therefore the possibility that a single voice definition is used simultaneously in multiple 'active' song sections) adds a lot to the implementation complexity I'd be happy to forgo it if it meant it was possible to quickly throw together an arrangement as a backing track with repeated sections only needing to be defined once (i.e. "intro verse chorus verse chorus bridge verse chorus outro")

  • 0
    Lucky_LuxLucky_Lux PolandPosts: 14
    edited November 2017

    Ron (rpc9943) I see one huge problem with your idea and it is the same as we have right now with creating the sections. You need to copy the same tracks, to use it in different sections. In the end, you have A LOT of redundant tracks and after awhile, you forget everything and you can not work with the song quickly. Your idea is common for drum machines, but they have only one track - drum track to handle with. I will be disappointed, if there will be no progress with the sections / song mode, because deluge have big capabilities. I can't believe they will be limited to the drum machine workflow. Deluge is capable to work as DAW and as far I know, many people bought it, to be able to not creating with software (as I'm, they working all day on computer, so they have enough of it) but on hardware.

    In my idea, you can still create a sections by choosing the section color in the "song mode level" for every track you want (using audition / section pad) to grope them and play / mute. Or you can crate sections in song view - as right now. This means, that the current workflow could be kept - for people who need it.

    Please tell me what is "very problematic potentially" in my idea.
    Thanks.

    Post edited by Lucky_Lux on
  • 2

    MY thoughts on song mode:

  • 0
    workergrayworkergray Posts: 113
    edited November 2017

    With a horizontal layout of song sections (instead of the current vertical) the "tails" of effects and notes could continue because the pattern isn't muted-- it's just stopped playing.

    Post edited by workergray on
  • 0

    Additionally-- the method I laid out would give you the ability to make a "scratch track" --like one beat running the length of the song so you could open another track for recording directly as a sample that would be as long as the song. The deluge becomes a multi-track recorder, essentially.

  • 1
    Lucky_LuxLucky_Lux PolandPosts: 14

    +1 for your idea Workergray
    Really good one with the displaying the length of the tracks! :smile:

  • 0
    rpc9943rpc9943 New York usaPosts: 136

    I disagree with both proposals, keep it simple, each pad would represent a color of the section, and would be able to duplicate by drawing it. If you want to mute out or change anything from a section just make a new section and draw it in. Simpler is best. These two ideas I see are unintuitive to me because if we layer multiple sections over each other it can run the risk of duplication which is not even supported in deluge currently. I say, simply this, draw in a section color , it would play it, draw in another color, it would play that. You cant get more simple than that. Just my view on it.

  • 0
    MyrkMyrk Taunton, UKPosts: 70
    edited November 2017

    workergray just curious, in your image does a fully lit button with 2 slightly dimmed (like the top red row) mean that sequence is 3 bars long (in which case all good), or 3 repeats of the section? If the latter, how do you differentiate between a pattern that is 3/16th notes long from one that is 8 bars long?

    I do think the idea is better than current, as a LOT of times I am making 8 bar lines where there are 4 bars of blank followed by 4 bars of notes - seems kinda wasteful to have 4 blank bars, and a bit annoying.
    This proposal also makes a lot more use of the 128 pads during song mode, as currently only 8 of those 128 pads are actually used!

    I also realised that having the ableton view would allow you to have WAAAY less tracks - track sharing can occur in riffs, and you could also have long tracks that can be utilized in shorter versions, so say an 8 bar track could be used in a 4 bar manner - either cutting off 4 bar or use a menu command to double time the riff, so you could utilize the same pattern in many different ways. Very powerful!

    I redrew your graphic... I think it might make more sense to people... lol!:

    https://www.myloops.net/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/Vocal-Trance-Essentials-Vol.-1-Ableton-Live-Template.png

    Post edited by Myrk on
  • 0
    rpc9943rpc9943 New York usaPosts: 136

    Okay having looked this over and talked with a few people on it, I see what you guys are proposing, it would be "better". I was only thinking hey I want a lane where I can just put in each section. It appears that you guys want "full daw clip" functionality. That would mean discarding sections altogether, if I'm not mistaken? Quite an interesting conversation here.

  • 0

    Ron-- I don't think it would necessarily do away with sections as they exist altogether. For instance, if you have two patterns based on the same instrument, if entered one into the timeline it could necessarily mute the other as long as the other was entered at a previous point in the timeline--- they would be more like mute-groups which could contain up to 12 (as per current specs)
    Myrk-- I see what you mean. I will redraw the pic and add some more specifications.

  • 1

    OK-- here's my revised proposal (*and an apology to Ron for hijacking his thread-- but it inspired me!)
    AT the 16-level zoom, all 4 bar patterns (16 step) will appear as a solid color pad. Any pattern that is longer will appear as that many pads long-- i.e. 2X16 note pattern (8 bars) would appear as 2 solid colored pads. Repeated patterns would appear as a lighter shade at that zoom level (or any zoom level).
    SHORTER patterns (i.e. less than 16 steps) would appear as lighter colors (like the repeats) at 16 zoom level.
    Zoom level 00.08 would show 2 bar patterns (8 steps) as one solid color pad. regular 4 bar (16 step) patterns would appear as 2 solid color pads, and so-on. Any shorter patterns would appear light colored at this zoom level.
    Additionally, you could select a pattern/repeats and introduce a fade-in, fad-out (volume) to last that long-- or other such effects at any zoom level-- which would contol that parameter for those "pads" for that time frame at that zoom level.
    Editing patterns would work the same way it always did. Tap anywhere in that row to open that pattern for editing.

  • 1
    workergrayworkergray Posts: 113
    edited November 2017

    The timeline would scroll by 1 pad at any given zoom level-- holding shift while <> scrolling would scroll by 1 screen at a time at any given zoom level.
    NOTE--- current timeline runs top to bottom. Proposed timeline runs left to right with no cap on length except your willingness to turn the dial. this increases song sections.
    The previous "song sections" color coding could be revised to make "mute sections" of multiple copies of the same instrument. For example-- supposing you have a regular beat that lasts 4 bars and a dozen "fills" made from the same kit that are 2 bars long. You just enter the regular beat for as many repeats as required and drop-in the fills on their respective lines where you want them to appear. They will "mute" the regular beat where they appear and the regular beat will continue playing after they resolve.

    Post edited by workergray on
  • 1
    22tape22tape Posts: 10

    At the risk of sounding like a broken record, I'd love to see some kind of traditional song mode implemented, be it by some of the great ideas here, or by a simple pattern-chaining function. Without this, I only use the Deluge as a composing tool that gets sampled into another sampler for arranging. And to be honest, if I have to sample my sampler into another sampler to finish songs, I might have to sell my Deluge for, say, a Microsampler, since I prefer to perform/compose on keys.

    Don't get wrong, I love the Deluge. It's an amazingly designed piece of gear. I realize that everyone's needs are different but I'm just not sure why, with groovebox workstations in general, traditional song modes aren't included. We're all musicians. We all make songs :)

  • 0
    DustyNeedleDustyNeedle BelgiumPosts: 6

    +1

Sign In or Register to comment.